Skip to content

Whether a posting is still open

We spot-check listings against the board that carried them and remove the ones that answer as gone. Most rows have not been checked, and say nothing.

Postings close and boards rarely announce it. We check stored listings against the board that published them, in batches, and when one answers with a removed page we stop showing it in search, in similar jobs, in match scores and in alert emails.

  • "Confirmed open", with how long ago, appears in the detail panel when a check actually answered for that listing.
  • "Closed, checked" with a date means the check found the posting removed. You can still reach a closed listing from your tracker or a shared link, so the panel says so instead of leaving you to find out on the board. Your tracker shows the same badge when you open a saved job.
  • "No longer listed" means the listing aged out of search. That is our rotation, not a sign the employer closed it, so check the posting itself before you rule it out.
  • "About this listing" in the detail panel lists what we have checked about a posting, each with the date it was true: whether it is on the employer's careers site, how long we have seen it, and whether it has been reposted. A line we could not check is left out rather than guessed.
  • Most listings show nothing there, and that means we have not looked, not that the job is gone.
  • Only positive evidence counts. A page that is gone, or a redirect that drops the posting id. A board refusing an automated request, rate-limiting us or timing out is recorded as unknown and changes nothing, because treating a refusal as an answer would bury enormous numbers of live listings.

Boards differ enormously. Some pull a listing within days of it closing, others leave it up indefinitely, and a few block automated checks entirely. Measured across the newest listings per board, about one in eight of what we were serving had already been taken down.

Where it stops

This catches a lot of it and not all of it, and we will not tell you the odds for a given listing. Whether a posting of a certain age is still open was measured and did not hold up: the order we check things in creates the pattern rather than age doing so. The posting date on the row is still your best guide.

Did this answer your question?

Still stuck? Ask us directly, and mention this article so we know where to start.